| Name | School | Place |
| Macharia Yuot | Widener University | 1 |
| Tim Finnegan | Calvin College | 2 |
| Julian Boggs | Colorado College | 3 |
| Willy Kaul | University of Wisconsin Oshkosh | 4 |
| Jed Christiansen | Calvin College | 5 |
| Ryan Place | Allegheny College | 6 |
| Will Leer | Pomona - Pitzer Colleges | 7 |
| Nicholas Hird | North Central College | 8 |
| James Nally | SUNY Cortland | 9 |
| Tyler Sigl | Unversity of Wisconsin Platteville | 10 |
| Matt Deshane | Plattsburgh State University | 11 |
| Jon Phillips | New York University | 13 |
| Hany Abdallah | New York University | 14 |
| Chris Dunker | Nebraska Wesleyan University | 15 |
| Harrison Jorritsma | Calvin College | 16 |
| Marco Dozzi | Allegheny College | 17 |
| Erik Van Kampen | Calvin College | 17 |
| Donald Letts | Haverford College | 18 |
| Colin Sanders | Vasser College | 19 |
| Ben Grant | Loras College | 20 |
| Jon Gries | Calvin College | 21 |
| Matthew Busche | Luther College | 21 |
| Jessie Schneider | New York University | 22 |
| Archie Abrams | Bowdoin College | 24 |
| Jessie Williamson | Rochester Institute of Technology | 25 |
| Zach Vaslow | Haverford College | 26 |
| Brian Kopnicki | College of New Jersey | 27 |
| Kelly Fermoyle | Saint John's University | 28 |
| Ryan Williams | New York University | 29 |
| Adam Bohach | Luther College | 30 |
| Nate Dehaan | Calvin College | 31 |
| Michah Lorenzen | Concordia University | 32 |
| Scott Lasch | Heidelberg College | 33 |
| James Butcher | Middlebury College | 34 |
| Chris Guerriero | College of New Jersey | 35 |
