| Name | School | Place |
| Josh Rohatinsky | Brigaham Young University | 1 |
| Neftalem Araia | Stanford University | 2 |
| Jess Baumgartner | University of Southern Utah | 3 |
| Lopez Lomong | University of Northern Arizona | 4 |
| Martin Fagan | Providence College | 5 |
| Galen Rupp | University of Oregon | 6 |
| Jacob Korir | Eastern Kentucky University | 7 |
| Peter Kosgei | University of Arkansas | 8 |
| Aaron Aguayo | Arizona State University | 9 |
| Robert Cheseret | University of Arizona | 10 |
| Stuart Eagon | University of Wisconsin | 11 |
| Brent Vaughn | University of Colorado | 12 |
| Stephen Samoei | University of Texas El Paso | 13 |
| Chris Rombough | University of Minnesota | 14 |
| Sean Quigley | La Salle University | 15 |
| Samuel Chelanga | Fairleigh Dickinson University | 16 |
| Kevin Chelimo | Texas Tech University | 17 |
| Tim Nelson | University of Wisconsin | 18 |
| Shadrack Songok | Texas A & M University - Corpus Christi | 19 |
| Stephen Pifer | University of Colorado | 20 |
| Phillip Reid | California Polytechnic State University | 21 |
| Mark Korir | University of Wyoming | 22 |
| Mohamed Khadroui | Iona College | 23 |
| Matt Withrow | University of Wisconsin | 24 |
| Seth Pilkington | Weber State University | 25 |
| Colby Wissel | University of Kansas | 26 |
| Josh McDougal | Liberty University | 27 |
| Erik Heinonen | University of Colorado | 28 |
| Francis Kasagule | Lamar University | 29 |
| Corey Nowitzke | Eastern Michigan University | 30 |
| Dan Mazzocco | Penn State University | 31 |
| Jordan Kyle | University of Indiana | 33 |
| Christo Landry | College of William and Mary | 34 |
| Patrick Smyth | University of Notre Dame | 36 |
| Joe Thorne | University of Texas | 37 |
| Dave Nightingale | Princeton University | 39 |
| Paul Hefferon | University of Kansas | 42 |
| Seth Summerside | University of Arkansas | 44 |
| J.D. Krawczyk | University of California Santa Barbara | 46 |
| James Strang | University of Colorado | 47 |
| Scott McPherson | University of Arkansas | 48 |
| Diego Mercado | University of Oregon | 49 |